Partners remade old New York City factories, shaped rehab of landmark Flatiron Building.
By Tim Darragh
Of The Morning Call
October 17, 2004
Just across the East River from Lower Manhattan stands a Brooklyn neighborhood that only a few years ago was a nearly forgotten land of aging, nondescript cardboard factories and an incinerator.
It's buzzing today with trendy lofts, offices and shops a place where its hipness is only exceeded by its peerless views of downtown and the iconic Manhattan and Brooklyn bridges.
Twenty years ago, Jeff Gural and Barry Gosin saw the potential in those factories with developer David Walentas. After years of delays, the partners, advised by attorney Richard Fischbein, parlayed a combination of tax breaks and high Manhattan real estate prices into the reborn neighborhood known as Down Under the Manhattan Bridge Overpass, or DUMBO.
Now, Gural, Gosin, Fischbein and two others want to give south Bethlehem its own extreme makeover. Together, the developers, leading names in New York City's high stakes legal and real estate fields, bring a formidable mixture of national real estate management, industrial redevelopment experience and political savvy to a project that has languished since Bethlehem Steel executives announced lofty renovation plans seven years ago.
The new owners envision transforming a moribund 120 acres of rusting steel mills and offices into a destination site of entertainment, shops and homes, while retaining the industrial essence of the land. The developers speak of an economic powerhouse for the region that also has the funky cultural charm of New Hope and Manyunk.
Ultimately, they say, their goal is to have the site, known as Bethlehem Works, mentioned in the same breath as Boston's Faneuil Hall or Baltimore's Inner Harbor.
The prospect of redeveloping the steel site through a partnership including James Kuhn, Gural and Gosin principals of Newmark & Co., one of New York's biggest comprehensive real estate companies and the politically connected Fischbein and Phillipsburg attorney Michael Perrucci, has turned one-time skeptics giddy with anticipation.
''I've been working on this project for seven years,'' said state Rep. T.J. Rooney, D-Lehigh/Northampton, a friend and former partner of Perrucci's who initially supported another developer. ''To think about where we were 2 1/2 years ago and to think about where we are today, it's a quantum leap. … I'm real encouraged, and I didn't start out there.''
Newmark is a major player in New York City's real estate market. It was the city's second-largest commercial property manager last year, according to a survey by Crain's New York Business.
Gosin said the group's experience with DUMBO shows that as developers, they know how to turn old manufacturing sites into viable dwellings, offices and shops while retaining their old city flavor.
But the Bethlehem Works site is a bigger redevelopment challenge, with its own icons the blast furnaces and other structures that are ''half fallen apart,'' said Gural, the Newmark chairman. The new owners announced last month that they hoped to redevelop the site generally following the entertainment/retail/office/residential idea first proposed by Bethlehem Steel in 1997.
But it's impossible to say what the site might look like, they said, because they haven't owned the property long enough to have a master plan drafted.
Still, Gosin, Newmark's vice chairman and chief executive officer, was more than optimistic that the redevelopment, however it finally comes about, will become a reality.
''The only question is when,'' Gosin said. ''It is not a question of if. It's a question of when. And so if it … happens to take 15 years, you know, we'll figure it out.''
Perrucci, a Phillipsburg lawyer with Pennsylvania ties, led the partners to the site and ''began a conversation'' with Fischbein, his law firm's managing partner. Fischbein also was a business partner and Hamptons beach neighbor of Wilbur Ross, who purchased bankrupt steelmakers including Bethlehem Steel and created International Steel Group. ISG last month sold the property to the five developers, working under the name BethWorks Now.
According to Perrucci, the Bethlehem Commerce Center site first interested the developers. The center consists of about 1,600 acres of former steel property being converted into an industrial park and truck and rail shipping yard. Unlike the Bethlehem Works site, commerce center properties could qualify for tax breaks. Lehigh Valley Industrial Park purchased most of the commerce center, however.
Then, as a pending sale of Bethlehem Works to Delaware Valley Real Estate Investment Fund foundered, the BethWorks Now developers stepped in, purchasing the property for $2 million in cash and another $1.1 million in other considerations. While Bethlehem Works land is not available for tax breaks, it does qualify for tax increment financing, which would direct increased tax revenues from the new development to pay off the tab for infrastructure improvements.
Five years … or 15 years
Since BethWorks Now entered the picture, a new element appeared on the horizon: slots.
Gaming operators, whom the developers declined to identify, contacted them with the prospect of a license for slot machines as part of the entertainment plans for the site. Immediately, the developers could see their dreams, fueled by a new lucrative source of cash, follow a much brisker path to reality than that taken by DUMBO.
''At the end of the day, if that were to happen, you take a project of 10-15 years … you've just made this project happen in five years,'' Gosin said. ''The certainty of success with gaming is 100 percent.''
The additional slots money that could be brought to the developers and Bethlehem would ''really help make something that may be uneconomical, economical,'' Perrucci said. ''It may allow something that you couldn't ordinarily do in a lifetime make economic sense. So there's this window of opportunity. I mean, whether we get that or not, we're excited about this site.''
Although they say that they entered the project without any thought of slots, the developers say their new concept of gambling with other mixed uses has proved to be successful.
''It's not a coincidence that the most successful casinos in Vegas are associated with big retail and family-style entertainment,'' Kuhn said.
Additionally, slots may take profit-making pressures off a proposed Smithsonian museum of industrial heritage, Gural said. The museum ''could be a do-good thing to honor the people who worked there when America was an industrial country,'' Gural said.
The Bethlehem Works site might not be the first shot at gambling for one of the developers. Gural is hoping to bring slots to a closed horse racing track just north of the Pennsylvania border in Tioga County, New York. A breeder and buyer of standardbred horses, Gural, along with a partner, John Simmonds, have applied for licenses to race horses and operate video slot machines at Tioga Park. The track hasn't hosted a race in 25 years.
Simmonds said plans eventually call for a hotel and estimated the partners will spend ''well north of $10 million'' by the time the project is done.
Doug Barton, director of Tioga County Department of Economic Development and Planning, said a horse racing-only facility would have welcome, but limited, economic benefit. Add slots, he said, and the picture changes.
''The combination of the two,'' Barton said, ''makes it a successful proposition.''
Political connections, donations
Slots licenses are a prized governmental commodity, and the developers over the years have not been bashful about getting local and national politicians' attention. As it is, Perrucci, a former Warren County Democratic Party chairman, was a law partner with former New Jersey Gov. Jim Florio. Their firm in 1999 merged with Fischbein's another politically tied firm that counts as members Herman Badillo, a former congressman, deputy mayor and adviser to former New York City Mayor Rudy Giuliani; and Liberal Party head Raymond Harding.
The five developers have contributed tens of thousands of dollars to state and national political figures and causes, usually but not always to Democrats. Perrucci, the former Democratic county chairman, wrote a $500 check to Pennsylvania Republican U.S. Sen. Rick Santorum in June, for instance. On the other hand, about a year ago, Perrucci gave $10,000 to the Pennsylvania state Democratic Party. Another $5,000 came from the law firm and Florio sent a third check of $1,000, all on the same day.
Campaign records show Perrucci gave Gov. Ed Rendell $1,000 when he ran for governor in 2002. The firm also gave $15,000 to Rendell.
Perrucci also is a Rooney campaign donor, as well as a former business partner of his. Tax returns released by Rooney show that he netted about $7,000 over the last two years for political consulting services to Perrucci, an arrangement that Rooney said was approved in advance by the state Ethics Commission. Rooney said once he learned that Perrucci's group would make an effort to buy the Bethlehem Works property, he severed his business ties with Perrucci.
''I want to be able to advocate for reputable people with no cloud hanging over my head,'' said Rooney, who also has received campaign donations from Perrucci.
''They understand how to leverage and get in front of the governor,'' said state Sen. Lisa Boscola, D-Northampton. Like Rooney, Boscola supported another developer initially, but since has been converted. ''Every time I talk with Mr. Perrucci, we're always talking politics,'' she said. ''I trust him.''
Boscola said Perrucci already has spoken with Rendell during a recent visit to the Valley and in Harrisburg. At the latter meeting, she said, ''the discussion revolved around a slot parlor.''
Heritage preservation possible
Whether they secure a license for slots, the developers said they intend to press forward with development plans. Perrucci said they are interviewing some of the nation's top architectural firms and may hold a ''beauty contest'' to see who comes up with the best development ideas that also retain as much industrial heritage as possible.
The developers say they won't make promises about what they can retain of the plant, acknowledging the legacy of promises rooted in the property from Bethlehem Steel days on through more recent, largely unfulfilled, redevelopment plans. Since Bethlehem Steel's decline, a few positive steps have become a reality, including the Flyers' Skate Zone ice rink and the landing of OraSure Technologies, a medical diagnostics firm. More numerous were the flops, including grand proposals calling for a 12-screen movie theater, a blues club, and an entertainment center called ''The Fundry.''
Bethlehem Mayor John Callahan said the developers understand the importance of retaining the industrial nature of the land.
''I made it very clear to them early on in our discussions that it was my wish to save the blast furnaces and that it was non-negotiable,'' Callahan said. ''They were not opposed'' to the concept, he said.
The chief executive officer of the proposed National Museum of Industrial History, Stephen Donches, also has been favorably impressed by the new owners.
''Their comments about interest in preservation of the project have been very supportive,'' Donches said. ''And have been very supportive of the National Museum of Industrial History.''
Donches said the group needs time to complete its assessment of the property before anyone can judge if those good intentions come to pass.
Another property owned by an investment group led by Gural, Gosin and Kuhn suggests that preservationists have reason to hope.
It is New York's famed Flatiron Building, regarded as one of the city's most recognizable and beloved structures. Built in 1902 by famed architect Daniel Burnham, the Beaux Arts-style building was under consideration to be converted into apartments, Gural said. But after rejecting the proposal, the Flatiron has undergone considerable renovation with attention to historical detail, said Peter Garabedian, chief operating officer of Holtzbrinck Publishers, which leases most of the office space in the building.
Garabedian said the owners are putting millions of dollars in renovations into the building, including refinishing the exterior stonework and adding new windows and bathrooms. And since the building is a historic structure, even details such as the windows down to the color of the paint have to pass muster with a city historical review commission.
Holtzbrinck recently signed a 15-year lease for the building. That, Garabedian said, reflects on the effort and expense that the owners put into the Flatiron.
Speaking of Gural, with whom he negotiated the lease, Garabedian said, ''I can't emphasize enough how thrilling he finds it to own a landmark. He wants it to reflect on him.''
Working with partners
The steel property owners say the industrial nature of the tract makes preserving as much as they can a no-brainer.
''The historical context makes it so spectacular,'' said Fischbein.
Fischbein said the group also was attracted to the ''unique'' idea of being able to redevelop a large site in the middle of an urban downtown. They are eager to find a partner to build a lifestyle center, a development of upscale shops and restaurants. Other developers have their eyes on sites in the Lehigh Valley for lifestyle centers, giving the BethWorks group a sense of urgency.
''Part of the issue that we will have is timing,'' Gosin said. ''We've got to do this quickly.''
The grind of Harrisburg political machinery may not allow BethWorks Now to reach all of its goals quickly, however. The state already is behind its own timeline for appointing a full Gaming Board. Eventually, the board will have to find office space, hire staff and develop regulations which has to happen soon if it is to have any chance of meeting Rendell's timetable of issuing the first slots license by December 2005.
As with other projects such as the DUMBO venture, the developers would not necessarily be the ones to do the work.
Jed Walentas, son of the DUMBO redeveloper, said his father was the visionary behind DUMBO, but Gural in particular helped keep things together, especially during the New York real estate market's lean years. ''Jeff gave us some financial and political stability that we didn't have, especially when times were bad,'' Walentas said.
Today, he said, nearly 3 million square feet of dying factory space has been converted into highly successful office, retail and housing space in DUMBO.
Walentas, who was unfamiliar with the Bethlehem Works project, warned that success in one real estate market is not a predictor of success in another. But, he added, the Newmark principals are good at what they do and would likely bring in a team with well-rounded expertise.
''We're very happy to joint-venture with people,'' Gosin said, adding that they would likely hire other developers to oversee construction of the lifestyle center and gaming facilities. The redevelopment of the Steel General Office building would likely stay in their hands, Gosin said, because that kind of work is ''really in our sweet spot.''
As with DUMBO, Gosin said the developers are in Bethlehem for the long haul.
''We're long-term investors,'' he said. ''We're not short-term guys. We don't buy and then flip.''
Added Kuhn: ''We put our money up. … We closed with cash on the property, and nobody has promised us a thing yet.''